The Predictability Predicament: Why Becky Lynch Winning the 2024 Royal Rumble Falls Flat

The Predictability Predicament: Why Becky Lynch Winning the 2024 Royal Rumble Falls Flat

e Royal Rumble is WWE's annual gateway to WrestleMania, a night where 30 men and 30 women vie for the golden opportunity to main event the biggest stage in sports entertainment. While surprises and shocking eliminations are the lifeblood of the Rumble, sometimes the most anticipated outcomes can fall flat. This year, Becky Lynch's potential victory in the women's Rumble presents a prime example of that predictability trap. While she's undoubtedly a star, a Lynch win would lack the narrative punch and long-term storytelling potential that could truly ignite the Road to WrestleMania.

The Obvious Choice:

Undeniably, Becky Lynch has all the credentials to be the 2024 Rumble winner. "The Man" is a multi-time champion, a fan favorite, and boasts a victory in the 2019 Rumble, making her the first-ever two-time winner a tantalizing prospect. Furthermore, her recent absence from the Raw Women's Championship picture hints at a potential return to the title scene through the Rumble's golden ticket. However, this very obviousness is the problem. Predicting a Lynch win is akin to guessing the sun will rise in the east; it's safe, but offers little excitement.

Narrative Stagnation:

A Lynch victory, while potentially satisfying for her fans, wouldn't shake up the current women's division in a meaningful way. We've already seen her battle Raw's current champion, Bianca Belair, numerous times. Putting them in another title feud feels uninspired and predictable. Additionally, a rematch with Rhea Ripley, the SmackDown Women's Champion, while potentially fresh, doesn't offer the long-term intrigue that the Rumble should plant.

Missed Opportunities:

By focusing on the "safe" choice of Lynch, WWE risks overlooking other talent with more compelling narratives. Imagine the shock value of Asuka, returning from injury with renewed ferocity, eliminating Lynch and claiming the Rumble victory. The potential for a dominant Asuka reign, challenging both champions, is far more intriguing than another predictable Lynch title run. Or picture the emotional impact of Liv Morgan, finally capitalizing on her underdog persona, throwing out the fan-favorite to secure her WrestleMania moment. These scenarios hold far more emotional weight and storytelling potential than yet another Becky Lynch title chase.

Building New Stars:

The Royal Rumble should be a platform to elevate new stars and reignite established ones. While Lynch is established, focusing solely on her potential win neglects the development of other talented women. Superstars like Rhea Ripley, Bianca Belair, Liv Morgan, Bayley, and Asuka all deserve opportunities to be thrust into the spotlight. A Rumble win for any of them would spark fresh feuds, inject new energy into the division, and create a more unpredictable path to WrestleMania.

Beyond the Obvious:

WWE has a rich history of defying expectations with Rumble winners. Remember Kofi Kingston's emotional victory in 2019, or Bianca Belair's dominant performance in 2021? These unexpected moments are what make the Rumble truly special. Choosing a winner who isn't the most obvious choice creates anticipation, builds suspense, and allows for more captivating storytelling on the Road to WrestleMania.

Conclusion:

Becky Lynch's talent and star power are undeniable. However, her potential Royal Rumble victory carries the weight of predictability. While it would be a safe route, it wouldn't be the most impactful decision for the women's division or the Rumble's legacy. By looking beyond the obvious and taking a chance on a less expected winner, WWE can maximize the Rumble's potential to generate excitement, build new stars, and craft compelling narratives that will truly captivate the audience on the Road to WrestleMania. Remember, the Rumble is about surprises, not fulfilling predictable outcomes. Let's hope WWE throws us a curveball and proves that the best is yet to come.